I have tried many eyeliners in the past and this one works best for me. I have sensitive eyes and nothing works better than this. Unfortunately, my local stores do not carry it anymore so I tried another brands and they made my eyelids peel drastically. Thank goodness I found it here on Amazon and in a double pack to boot!

This is a dark brown shimmery eyeliner. The felt tip is very skinny, which is nice for precision. The formula isn't streaky, but it is thin, so it might be hard to use for people with shaky hands. It also doesn't seem to be very waterproof, but it has enough water resistance that it'll hold up if you're not rubbing it while wet. According to the label, it is made in Germany and should be used within 9 months of opening. The picture shows what it looks like (line on the right) of what it looks like next to a brown pencil liner from Rimmel.

I started wearing eyeliner again and I tried a few which were just about ok. I gave this a go and I like that it as easy to apply, dries fast, didn't smudge and stayed as long as 10 hrs. I don't know how it would do if someone wore this when working out

I’ve been searching for a dupe for the NYX liner that was discontinued and finally found my holy grail! This one has a long, thin tip, making it easier to swipe the liner into a wing, and into a perfectly sharp tip. The liner is EXTRA black and doesn’t move when I’m sweating in hot, humid weather. It also doesn’t burn my eyes like others do. If you’re looking for the perfect liner, look no further!!

I use this daily. I need something water resistant and this is great The thin brush makes it easy to apply.

It is NOT waterproof or smudge proof, but it does last most of the day and still looks good up until bedtime. But it has a really good brush and goes on easy.

For some reason, black pen eyeliners seem to generally flow well, while brown doesn't. Black is too stark for my coloring, and I was completely disenchanted with multiple brands of brown that were dry, flaky, and/or like trying to apply with a fat crayon. (Sometimes when the same brand in black worked great.) Then I found the Revlon ColorStay Mahogany Flame. LOVE IT! Here's why: 1) It's not a pen, but it has the flow and precision of one. The tip of the brush is just right--the point allows you to make a barely visible thin line, but if you load the brush with product, you can get a nice bold effect. 2) The color is GORGEOUS. It's almost a copper color. Subtle but strong. 3) It lasts. I tend to have oily skin, so some eyeliners will pretty much just melt off shortly after application. When I come home from work 10 hours after I applied this eyeliner, it's still there. 4) Super affordable! This is SO inexpensive, and if you want to save even more, you can get it through Subscribe & Save. Cons: 1) If you get this in your eye, it stings. That's pretty typical of most cosmetics--they don't belong IN your eye. But when you're working this close to the eye, it's going to happen once in awhile. So just a word of caution. (If you found this review helpful, I'd really appreciate if you would click the "Helpful" button. Thanks so much for reading! Liz)

I like a nice sharp wing and this is the only liner ive found that can get it. It lasts as long as i dont rub my eyes or get teary. Strong black color

Love this! I have big eyes and do not need a bold liner. It's Right balance.

I’ve tried a lot of different eyeliners over the years but I seem to keep doming back to this one. It’s really well pigmented and does not fade throughout the day like the NYX one I used for awhile. The tip is pretty fine so you can get fairly precise with it. Fine enough to be fairly forgiving if you make a little mistake. All in all, you really can’t beat it for the price.