Clumpy, doesn’t glide on smoothly at all. Won’t be using this at all.

I don't understand why this has good review. Maybe the product that I got was defected? I don't know. This eyeliner is terrible. It leaves black residues under my eyes and makes it look like I have a dark circle. It is thin so easy to use but it makes a mass on my face so I won't be using this again.

The item description says "Ultra-fine tip, Waterproof, Smudgeproof, Longwearing" but actually none of these apply to this product!!! It is not at all a waterproof, it smudges with a slightest swipe and longwearing really?!! with one splash of water your all eyeliner will be on your face melted completely!!! Also, tip? it's not a tip by the way!!! it's like a cotton thread you can't ever draw a line with it. I had complained about this to Amazon, but no action or compensation from either the seller or from Amazon!

The applicator is a hard foam not a brush.

I don’t like this eyeliner cause it not last for a long time I’m not sure the problem is from the brush or the ink .

The eyeliner I received was manufactured in 2016 and not safe for consumer consumption over 5+ years later, even if unopened. The fact that I can't return this due to the shipping policy is unfair. Cancelled my 4-month recurring subscription. It's safer to buy this in-store where you can see the product's manufacture date before purchasing.

El delineador se corre completamente. No aguanta ni mediodía. Y ni siquiera estaba haciendo mucho movimiento, trabajo en Home Office. No lo recomiendo.

I bought this thinking it would be the very same as the standard Revlon colorstay eyeliner that I love and the best I've ever used, always comeback to that one for over a decade. BUT, the skinny version which should be about the brush being thinner, but not, its so watery and transparent nothing like the regular one. Useless and cant returned since I opened it up past the return time allowed.

It’s just waste of Money ... I will not give the opnion for this .....I just spend almost $12 ... it’s just use less .... but no option for return... bad think ....

The last one i recieved smudged, was watery and the pigment was off. Maybe because I bought it when it was on sale they gave us a defective product which os really sad because i usually LOVE the skinny liner. Before I could wear it all day now it wont even come on cleanly and half of it is gone after a few hours. Disappointed.