Our customers say Excellent
4.53
out of 5 based on
76079
reviews
Customer Reviews
3.9 out of 5
658 customer reviews
5 Stars
60%
4 Stars
7%
3 Stars
8%
2 Stars
9%
1 Stars
16%

Filtered to: 1 Star Ratings

NR123


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Cosmetic flaw: finish rubbing off

I love Magnolia products; however, this one has some manufacturing issues. I purchased one, got it home and realized there were some cosmetic flaws—the veneer or finish had rubbed off. Then I went back to the store to exchange it but found that nearly 7/8 of the remaining stock had this exact issue. It’s not supposed to be a distressed look. I found one that seemed to be without the cosmetic issue, but upon opening the covered portion at home, found it again. It’s a beautiful mirror and I wish it didn’t have this defect. But at this great price point, I could see why the manufacturing is what it is. Sadly will be returning the second one.


Momma Elf


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
fun house mirror

beautiful design but it's a fun house mirror


Shannon


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Scratched up mirror

It came very very scratched, chunks of missing wood. In order to get a refund I had to ship back and repackage it it. What a hassle. I just kept it and bought a wood pen to try and hide the scratches and the chunks missing because who has time to go through all that. Their should be quality control this was clear how they packaged and sent it all messed up.


Ashley


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Beautiful Design But Poor Quality Material

The quality of this product does not match the rest of the hearth and hand line. I have now ordered two separate natural color mirrors and both have arrived with the finish scratched off and the mirror is like a fun house mirror. The outer wood look veneer gets stuck to the box and just peels off. Since we intended to use this in a bathroom we will be returning for a higher quality piece. Joanna would not be pleased in the slightest to hear her products have these kind of defects. Beautiful design but very poor quality.


mamabear


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Finish rubbed off by packaging

I'm so disappointed. I've been so excited to hang this mirror, but when I opened the packaging I found that the finish had rubbed off where the cardboard was touching it. I had sorted through several in store to find one that didn't appear to have any damage, only to find that the one good one I found wasn't good after all. I expected better from Magnolia.



Jackie


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Disappointment

Should of listened to other reviews. Finish is peeling around the whole mirror and it looks terrible. Will be returning.


Disappointed


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Funhouse mirror

This mirror was great until I looked closer. I would have been able to ignore the imperfections had the actual mirror been okay. When looking at this mirror it is like you are in a fun house! The actual mirror has a weird warp to it that not only looks cheap and awful but is headache inducing. I wish i could ignore the funhouse effect because otherwise the idea of the mirror is cute!


Lisa


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Poor quality

I wanted to love this mirror which I why I bought THREE of them, but every single one the frame was damaged with knicks and scuffs and was unacceptable. I even went to two different Targets and the ones in store weren’t any better. I wanted this mirror but it clearly has quality control issues. Very disappointed.


Jo


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Low quality, distorted mirror.

The frame looks great, but the mirror is poor quality. I specifically bought this one because I assumed Magnolia wouldn’t sell a cheap mirror that was distorted, but this one is. My kids call it the “circus mirror” because that’s exactly what it looks like. Not the level of quality I expected something to have with the Magnolia name on it. I’ll be returning it.


Disapoibted in Magnolias


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-18
Crap product

Yep. Ordered online for in store pick up. Scratches all over the frame and mirror was as most others said...an funhouse mirror. Returned without even leaving the store.


Track A Package
Issue(s) With An Order
Warranty FAQ
customer service

Have questions? We're here to help!