Haven’t opened them yet, but odor looks good.

I needed a new shower liner, and this one has been much better than what I normally get in the store. I wish I could give 4.5 stars, because it's better than 4 but needing a little more weight at the bottom to help stop blowing into the shower keeps it from getting 5. I haven't had to machine wash it yet, so I'm not sure how well that will hold up, but it's good to know that's a option, especially when you have a cat that sometimes confused the shower for a litterbox.