Our customers say Excellent
4.53
out of 5 based on
76043
reviews
Customer Reviews
3.7 out of 5
52 customer reviews
5 Stars
52%
4 Stars
15%
3 Stars
6%
2 Stars
4%
1 Stars
23%

Filtered to: 1 Star Ratings

JP_NH


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-05-04
Runs way small in the waist

I have about 12 brands of jeans all size 34/34 that fit perfectly. That includes three pairs of Goodfellow Slim and Slim Straight. These are the only 34/34 jeans I've purchased in the last 10 years that have a waist that is so small they can't even be buttoned. The stupid thing is the legs fit fine. It's like they mislabled the size. I would almost be sure they are a 33 waist. Attached is a photo of these 34/34 aligned with a brand new pair of Goodfellow 34/34 Slim Straight. You can see the size difference. Also, the button is riveted further inside than the other Goodfellow jeans. Chalking this one up to bad quality control. Bottom line try them on first before buying or size up.


Mikaela


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Returning.

Worn them twice, stained all my shirts with big brown blotches that won’t come out in the wash. And now has what looks like water marks all over the pants. whatever dye they used, for these was terrible.


Jay


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
poor quality dye

I have several Goodfellow products, which are generally satisfactory. However, this particular item(dark blue) is an exception. The dye job was poorly done, and it ended up staining my shoes, shirt, watch strap, etc. Despite soaking it overnight and washing it multiple times, I haven't had any luck and it still stains the stuffs.


Maverick


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Two different Pairs of pants Ruined after 1 wash

I've bought two of the same pair of jeans, specifically the khaki jeans, and they both somehow had the color washed away in spots. All of my other Good Fellow products, 5/5 stars, they're great, but these were the biggest waste of money. Both look like they got stained, but the color just faded out on the first wash. I got a second thinking it was somehow my own error, but the exact same result when I washed the second pair. It's super subtle at first but the moment you walk into direct sunlight you can see the color start to turn to a slight purple hue


Tkmb


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Beware of fading and light purple blotches

I bought two pairs for two different people. Both pairs were washed in different households on cold and hung to dry. Both pairs came out with blotchy purple spots all over.



Will


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Pants ruined after 1 wash

I purchased these pants because they felt great and had excellent give to them. I put them in the wash with normal clothes and normal detergent and they came out with a bleach effect to them. I chalked it up as a fluke that I had done something wrong so I bought another pair and it happened again! Be careful if you buy the brown pair of these pants.


Sarah


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Discolored after washing as directed

I ordered this pair of pants for my husband and he love but but after I washed them as directed the came out with blotchy purple spots. I thought it was just a defective pair of pants so they replaced them for me., got the new pair in yesterday and washed them as directed once more and they came out a completely different color with a purple hue to them.. so disappointing and confusing!


a rodriguez


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
beware of discoloring

can't speak for all colors, but all other reviews describing discoloration after one wash are truthful. took a minute for me to notice, but especially out in natural light, it's BAD. makes them look filthy or like you got the juice that comes out of your trash bag when it's all nasty got all over them. feel bad for anyone who paid full price for these, i regret buying and i got them half off. dont recommend these at all, or at least not in the brown color.


lhughes


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
They discolor after washing!

They discolor after washing. We bought 2 pairs and they both have turned a purple color. Will not be buying again!!


AB


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2025-04-19
Turned purple after washing as directed

These pants looked so comfortable and were a great shade of brown before washing. They were also longer than 30". I will be returning and just too bad because they were a great find and price but my husband won't wear purple pants!


Track A Package
Issue(s) With An Order
Warranty FAQ
customer service

Have questions? We're here to help!