Was hoping they would be a little warmer, but they are okay.

They are not for sub-freezing temperatures. Have not worn them in rain but believe they may have good water resistance. Need one size up. Price is OK.

Very good value, but it's a bit stiff. and not very warm

they are good fit but make sure you order at least 1 size larger than you would or they might not fit well.

The reason that I gave these gloves four stars out of five is because I am unable to test how warm they keep my hands as the weather has been very warm here in the Catskill Mountains for the month of December. When it gets cold (which it will soon) I will try them out to see how they do when I am shoveling snow.

Fit well and comfy and warm.