It fits right and will keep your hands warm. It has soft lining and outer shell. There is nothing to dislike about this product. I gave this 4 stars because it should be more waterproof.

use it for early in the morning fishingwarm and feel good but it is not water proof though

Comfortable and durable!

I bought these gloves not for fishing, but for working on a dock where I regularly need to shuffle through paperwork or tap on a touch screen. At the same time, I want my hands to be warm as I work outside in the winter and I want the option to cover my fingers when it gets really cold or I don't need to touch any paperwork for awhile. There are mittens like this where the you can cover or uncover all four fingers at once, but the problem with those is that when it is cold, I want the majority of my fingers to be covered while retaining the ability to shuffle through paperwork.These gloves were perfect for that as you really only need two fingers on each hand to do that.The only issue with them is that I'd like to see some kind of velcro or magnets to hold the finger/thumb piece away from you while you aren't using them. As it stands, when you stick your finger/thumb through the hole, the remainder of that part of the glove kind of sticks out and can get in the way of things. You might be able to solve this by purchasing a few tiny magnets and super glueing them to the finger/thumb, but I have yet to try this.If they solve that issue, these will be the perfect dockworker gloves.

Used them once so far. Not bad. Braided line did not destroy the thumb, like I thought might happen. They did stay pretty dry. A little water seeped in. They are decent gloves for the price.

Seem fine and I love the design idea. Unfortunately, M were too long and loose for my hands (I usually wear a Women’s M in gloves). I wish they sold S.

These are dope and they keep my hands warm when it is 30-40 degrees outside

XL doesn't fit for me by length, 2XL would be more ok I think

These are comfortable, but not real warm, if temp is below 20 degrees find a different option

The Rubber / padded areas are a little slicker than anticipated, making it easier to have phone slip.They will work in usual Ohio winter conditions but not likely to be effectively warm below 10 to 20 deg F. Still, better than nothing. Mitten cover and magnetic features in exposable finger tips offered in other models likely to better meet the needs of very cold weather hunters, fishermen, and photographers.