Our customers say Excellent
4.53
out of 5 based on
76031
reviews
Customer Reviews
4.3 out of 5
124 customer reviews
5 Stars
70%
4 Stars
9%
3 Stars
8%
2 Stars
6%
1 Stars
6%

Filtered to: 1 Star Ratings

Kaidyn


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Disappointed

I bought two pairs of the same exact jeans, just in different colors. They are supposed to be the Men's Skinny Fit Jeans by Goodfellow & Co. The gray pair fit as expected, they are soft, stretchy, and obviously have some spandex in them which is why I got them in the first place. The black pair feel like a different fabric entirely, they have absolutely zero give or spandex, and they are significantly smaller despite supposedly being the same exact size and type. This isn't the first time I've received inconsistent items from Target, but at least the sizes are sort of correct this time. Y'all can do better, Target. For nearly $30 a pair, at the very least you could make sure that the sizing and fabric are as described.


Shopper


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Size doesn't match description

Not even remotely close to the size they state. I have khakis from this company in a bigger size (30x31) that fit me perfect. These jeans are 1 inch smaller on the waste (30x30) on the description here, but are so gigantic in actuality that I have to return them.


Roxytee


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Bad size quality control

These jeans measured almost 36" (17.75 across) instead of 34"! They are way too big. Bad quality control.


J


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Awful fit

Don’t fit the other pants of the same size. Frankly they don’t even fit correctly compared to other pairs of the exact same pants. Way to stretchy and generally uncomfortable.


Miss Britt


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Very skinny

A bit too skinny. Tight tight fitting.,



ravensnix


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Sizing is way off, even between same sizes. Extremely thin material which would have been good for summer but not if they keep falling off and bunching up in wrong places.

The size and cut is seriously off. I have purchased several pairs 2 in each size 30x32 32x32 and 32x30, every single one fits differently. I have a 28in inseam. The 30 inseams are to short. The 30 waists are to small but the 32s fall off. All of them are baggy in the knees and the hem flairs outward. I only bought them because my usual brand was having availability issues. I will never buy target brand pants again.


James


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Size has changed

I've been getting the Goodfellow skinny jeans for the last few years and have found them to fit perfect and are my favorite jeans. I recently purchaced a new pair of these, only to find the cut has completely changed. Be aware, they are now much smaller with a lower rise than previous and tighter around the thighs.


AS


Third Party Review
Reviewed: 2024-08-16
Three strikes

Just the worst pair of jeans ever. I was taken aback because I’m usually a real fan of Goodfellow&Co and usually the quality is very decent. I have a pair of corduroy pants from Goodfellow that I love and that are great quality. But these…barely any belt loops so it’s hard to hold them up properly, the waistband folds over because it’s so badly constructed, the fabric is so thin. It’s just an all around awfully constructed piece of clothing. The grain of the denim also looks extremely fake. Plus, sizing is VERY inconsistent. I bought a 38 waist previously and a 36 and they’re both the same size essentially. It’s a no on fit/comfort, a no on look, and a no on value.


Track A Package
Issue(s) With An Order
Warranty FAQ
customer service

Have questions? We're here to help!